Därför kommer fri vilja att finnas kvar

published Jun 24, 2007 08:57   by admin ( last modified Jun 24, 2007 08:57 )
Det blossade upp en lite diskussion häromdagen på bloggen om fri vilja, apropå det jag skrev om en artikel i The Economist. Nu var det ju inte fri vilja jag ville diskutera primärt, utan om vidare upptäckter om hjärnan, skulle visa att kriminella inte kan hjälpa sina handlingar. Steven Pinker har tydligen sagt nedanstående:

Harvard’s Pinker figures that we can simultaneously believe in a fully caused human being and an ethical system that holds people responsible for their actions by imagining ethics as a “game” that it is useful for us to play for social purposes. In How the Mind Works, he writes that “the ethics game treats people as equivalent, sentient, rational, free-willed agents, and its rules are the calculus that assigns moral value to behavior through the behavior’s inherent nature or its consequences. Free will is an idealization of human beings that makes the ethics game playable.” The results of that game, he concludes, “can be sound and useful even though the world, as seen by science, does not really have uncaused events.”
Och det är väl ett rimligt sätt att se det på, om man skulle nå fram till att förstå hjärnan så grundligt. Fast jag tror inte man når dit.

Läs mer: Reason Magazine - 'You Can't See Why on an fMRI'